By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
TechgoonduTechgoonduTechgoondu
  • Audio-visual
  • Enterprise
    • Software
    • Cybersecurity
  • Gaming
  • Imaging
  • Internet
  • Media
  • Mobile
    • Cellphones
    • Tablets
  • PC
  • Telecom
Search
© 2023 Goondu Media Pte Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Banning, curtailing VPN could set unwanted precedent for Singapore
Share
Font ResizerAa
TechgoonduTechgoondu
Font ResizerAa
  • Audio-visual
  • Enterprise
  • Gaming
  • Imaging
  • Internet
  • Media
  • Mobile
  • PC
  • Telecom
Search
  • Audio-visual
  • Enterprise
    • Software
    • Cybersecurity
  • Gaming
  • Imaging
  • Internet
  • Media
  • Mobile
    • Cellphones
    • Tablets
  • PC
  • Telecom
Follow US
© 2023 Goondu Media Pte Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
Techgoondu > Blog > Internet > Banning, curtailing VPN could set unwanted precedent for Singapore
Internet

Banning, curtailing VPN could set unwanted precedent for Singapore

Alfred Siew
Last updated: August 28, 2016 at 11:33 AM
Alfred Siew
Published: August 26, 2016
8 Min Read
SHARE
PHOTO: iStockphoto
PHOTO: iStockphoto

It’s worrying that the Singapore government is reviewing the legality of virtual private networking (VPN) technology here, citing copyright concerns as a reason.

At the heart of the issue is whether people who use the technology to watch TV programmes and movies meant for overseas markets are deemed to be infringing the copyright of content owners.

If you ask consumers, they’d say it’s perfectly legit to watch Netflix shows meant for the United States, given the meagre selection in Singapore. After all, they still pay Netflix; they are not pirates.

What about the folks who own the rights and want to carve out the world into neat geographical regions to maximise profits? Of course, anything that messes with their business model has to be fought against.

Consumers don’t play by their rules any more, and they know it. Hours after each Game of Thrones episode is out, pirates would have already shared it online and everyone in the office would seem to have watched it even before it was telecast in Singapore.

But VPN technology is not piracy. It just allows people to unblock this geographically parcling-up of the world that the content industry is keen to preserve. Many users of VPN services are paying customers of streaming services, ranging from Netflix to Amazon Prime.

So, VPNs have always been a grey area, if you ask lawyers. By accessing such services, you’re often deemed to be buying parallel imports. No, these are not stolen goods you’re buying, but they are not sold by the local distributor.

Do you have a right to use these goods? Well, in a shipping hub like Singapore, you’d say yes, of course. Otherwise, so many of the goods sold here would be deemed illegal if the country outlawed parallel imports.

However, the authorities seem to have heard the other side of the argument, which is that these goods (or services) cannot be deemed legal because consumers have no right to consume them, even if they had paid for them.

Indeed, by using tools such as VPN, they would have circumvented a copyright protection measure, as the argument goes.

The same concept has been established in game consoles – today, you cannot plug in a gizmo or install software to defeat the copyright technology in an Xbox or Playstation even though you had paid for the game console.

If the authorities buy this argument, no doubt lobbied for by players with a lot to lose to an unblocked market, then they will have come to a decision that will limit choices in Singapore. They will also redraw the line when it comes to parallel imports.

There’s precedent here. Not very long ago, Singapore was under pressure to do something similar to DVD players.

Before it signed a free trade agreement with the United States in 2003, motion picture copyright owners argued that people here should not be allowed to play (Region 1) DVDs meant for the US with their multi-region players.

That, they argued would be circumventing a copyright protection measure, which was illegal.

Fortunately, the Singapore authorities disagreed. It would have been absurd for multi-region DVD players to be banned just so that movie studios can neatly divide up the market for themselves.

Region coding wasn’t meant to protect the content, but merely to segregate markets, the Singapore side argued. And rightly so.

Not many Singapore movie buffs knew it then, but they could have been stuck with Region 3 discs meant for the region, instead of playing back DVDs bought from Amazon.

Consumers won’t be so lucky this time if the Singapore government bowed to the pressure exerted once again by such lobby groups. It has to apply the same principle it did with the DVD region-coding situation.

The geographical blocking of users for video streaming services is to enable copyright owners to market their content to each region for the highest profit.

Consumers who have paid for a service should not be seen to be tempering with copyright protection measures. At worst, a user can be locked out of a service because he has breached the terms and conditions when he signed up.

It cannot be that he is seen as a pirate, like someone who is trying to unlock his Xbox or Playstation to play pirated games. Or that he is downloading pirated content from a peer-to-peer site.

As a market observer noted in a Straits Times report today, there are already existing measures that content owners can take to enforce their rights.

“Why even consider banning VPN if remedies are available? To help save legal costs for copyright holders at huge public cost for Singapore?” said Michael Tan, the director of an IT company.

And let’s not forget that VPN itself is a technology used largely for corporate users, not couch potatoes trying to view Netflix.

The technology, first of all, came about because travelling executives wanted to connect back to their company servers over the vast Internet, which was by and large a Wild Wild West of online servers.

By encrypting the data as it travelled through the Net, a user can keep away prying eyes while exchanging data securely.

Sure, VPN is used to unblock video content today. But restricting or outlawing its use will surely set Singapore back years as a business, financial and technology hub.

How will corporate users connect remotely without VPN? Even in China, you can access Facebook and other banned sites through a VPN service.

That will surely weigh heavily on the authorities when they sift through views from the public in the next two months. They also have to consider the unintended consequence of more, not less, piracy.

Do they ban or curtail a technology that has allowed parallel imports so far, knowing full well that such a decision could drive people to go back to downloading or streaming from pirated sites again?

StarHub to sell game downloads online
SingTel: no plans to charge consumers separately for WhatsApp
Amazon seized more than 2 million counterfeit products in 2020
Five cloud computing tips for SMBs
Google Store Singapore starts shipping Google Home, phones and more
TAGGED:copyright circumventionIPOSMinistry of LawNetflixonline streamingSingaporeVPN

Sign up for the TG newsletter

Never miss anything again. Get the latest news and analysis in your inbox.

By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Share This Article
Facebook Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Copy Link Print
Avatar photo
ByAlfred Siew
Follow:
Alfred is a writer, speaker and media instructor who has covered the telecom, media and technology scene for more than 20 years. Previously the technology correspondent for The Straits Times, he now edits the Techgoondu.com blog and runs his own technology and media consultancy.
Previous Article Goondu review: Sony PS-HX500 record player
Next Article New HP laptops come with built-in privacy screens
4 Comments
  • Chinmoy Kanjilal says:
    February 23, 2017 at 7:06 pm

    It’s good to see that Singapore took a stand against the evil that RIAA and MPAA have become. Their attitude towards copyright is ridiculous at times. Moreover, Singapore is a critical tourist destination and VPN is used by numerous people who travel because they want their favorite services to work seamlessly when away from home.

    Reply
  • Karen Bannan says:
    September 1, 2016 at 2:22 am

    “But restricting or outlawing its use will surely set Singapore back years as a business, financial and technology hub.” Yup. Corporate folks cannot live without VPN, especially as we move deeper into the cloud/mobile computing/remote worker era. Great IDC white paper that explains what goes into choosing a VPN service and why it’s so important here: bit.ly/2btoFKy

    –Karen Bannan, commenting for IDG and AT&T

    Reply
  • Elyse Alexander says:
    August 30, 2016 at 9:34 pm

    Most of the people are in Singapore are using VPNs ( https://www.purevpn.com/singapore-vpn-service.php ) for online security including me. What if our online data got hacked or something happened bad. Will our gov. responsible for this ?

    Reply
  • Peter says:
    August 30, 2016 at 5:13 pm

    100% agree!

    Reply

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Stay Connected

FacebookLike
XFollow

Latest News

Fujifilm GFX100RF review: Fun medium-format street photography camera
Imaging
May 14, 2025
Looks over AI? Samsung pitches slimmed-down Galaxy S25 Edge
Cellphones Mobile
May 13, 2025
Stunning AI advancements could transform healthcare, education and agriculture globally: Bill Gates
Internet
May 7, 2025
NRF 2025 APAC show in Singapore to spotlight latest in retail innovation
Enterprise
May 7, 2025

Techgoondu.com is published by Goondu Media Pte Ltd, a company registered and based in Singapore.

.

Started in June 2008 by technology journalists and ex-journalists in Singapore who share a common love for all things geeky and digital, the site now includes segments on personal computing, enterprise IT and Internet culture.

banner banner
Everyday DIY
PC needs fixing? Get your hands on with the latest tech tips
READ ON
banner banner
Leaders Q&A
What tomorrow looks like to those at the leading edge today
FIND OUT
banner banner
Advertise with us
Discover unique access and impact with TG custom content
SHOW ME

 

 

POWERED BY READYSPACE
The Techgoondu website is powered by and managed by Readyspace Web Hosting.

TechgoonduTechgoondu
© 2024 Goondu Media Pte Ltd. All Rights Reserved | Privacy | Terms of Use | Advertise | About Us | Contact
Join Us!
Never miss anything again. Get the latest news and analysis in your inbox.

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.
 

Loading Comments...
 

    Welcome Back!

    Sign in to your account

    Username or Email Address
    Password

    Lost your password?