By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
TechgoonduTechgoondu
  • Audio-visual
  • Enterprise
    • Software
    • Cybersecurity
  • Gaming
  • Imaging
  • Internet
  • Media
  • Mobile
    • Cellphones
    • Tablets
  • PC
  • Telecom
Search
© 2023 Goondu Media Pte Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: Can a new cellphone operator boost competition in Singapore?
Share
Aa
TechgoonduTechgoondu
Aa
  • Audio-visual
  • Enterprise
  • Gaming
  • Imaging
  • Internet
  • Media
  • Mobile
  • PC
  • Telecom
Search
  • Audio-visual
  • Enterprise
    • Software
    • Cybersecurity
  • Gaming
  • Imaging
  • Internet
  • Media
  • Mobile
    • Cellphones
    • Tablets
  • PC
  • Telecom
Follow US
© 2023 Goondu Media Pte Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
Techgoondu > Blog > Mobile > Cellphones > Can a new cellphone operator boost competition in Singapore?
CellphonesMobile

Can a new cellphone operator boost competition in Singapore?

Alfred Siew
Last updated: July 28, 2014 at 4:04 AM
Alfred Siew Published May 3, 2014
5 Min Read
SHARE

IDA_Singapore_Logo

Ask any Singapore cellphone user if he is happy these days and chances are you will hear a litany of complaints. From frequent network outages to higher 4G prices, users here have had to contend with a frustrating experience when they peer into their little screens of late.

Thus when news broke last week of a government push for new players to enter the Singapore market, many consumers could be forgiven for hoping for a change.

Could the Infocomm Development Authority’s attempt to bring in a so-called mobile virtual network operator (MVNO) give competition a boost? These operators would not own their own networks but could instead pay existing players for the capacity to serve customers.

The upside is that such operators would not need to shell out the millions to build a separate network. They can quickly concentrate on areas such as marketing and customer service to differentiate themselves.

Problem is, MVNOs are not new to Singapore. Back in 2001, new challenger Virgin Mobile entered the market and lasted barely a year. Reason for its failure? The market was too saturated and hard to crack.

Today, with a penetration rate of more than 150 per cent, Singapore’s mobile market is even more saturated. If it was hard to force your way in more than 10 years ago, today it could be even harder.

Don’t forget that every dollar earned by such MVNOs would also partly go into the coffers of the existing operators, empowering them to compete even harder.

Thus it is not surprising that nobody has come in to challenge the Big Three of SingTel, StarHub and M1 recently. There are now a small number of MVNOs here, but they serve niche markets and cater to less than 1 per cent of the 8.4 million mobile lines here.

For any new entrant to have a chance, the regulator would have to come up with new rules to level the playing field. For example, contracts between operators would have to be made transparent and open, the same way with fibre broadband today. This would allow new players to negotiate a fair wholesale price from the big players to stand a chance to compete.

Such regulations could also be controversial. Existing players would ask why they have to carve up part of their network to share with a new competitor, and possibly at a pre-defined price. Considering that they have had to improve their networks of late, thanks to more stringent checks by the regulator, they will not be willing to let a rival ride on the investments they have made.

If there is a sign that things could change, however, it’s that competition seems to be have slowed in the past two years.

After fighting hard to sign up users with the first Apple iPhone’s launch a few years ago, operators have recently cut back on the amount of free Internet data for smartphone users.

StarHub will also be raising prices for 4G services – a scenario that was unthinkable previously because users expected competition to be stiffer and technology to be more efficient, not less.

If all three operators raise prices for 4G in future, can a new entrant do things differently? That’s what users will hope for. As existing players start thinking they can take things easy, an opening could present itself to challengers.

A broadband service provider, such as Viewqwest or SuperInternet, for example, could bundle a mobile service with its home broadband offering. That would bring much-needed choice to consumers. What the new players will need are market conditions to change drastically for them to have a fighting chance.

NOTE: A version of this article also appeared in The New Paper.

You Might Also Like

Garmin Forerunner 965 review: Fully packed for serious fitness buffs

With more foldable phones in 2023, which one should you buy?

Google Pixel 7a review: Smaller, cheaper phone is smart but comes with trade-offs

Almost half of Singapore logistics firms still use manual tracking: Here study

Singtel starts offering Azure public MEC to all businesses

TAGGED: 4G, IDA, MVNO, Singapore, StartHub

Sign up for the TG newsletter

Never miss anything again. Get the latest news and analysis in your inbox.

By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Alfred Siew May 3, 2014
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Copy Link Print
Share
Avatar photo
By Alfred Siew
Follow:
Alfred is a writer, speaker and media instructor who has covered the telecom, media and technology scene for more than 20 years. Previously the technology correspondent for The Straits Times, he now edits the Techgoondu.com blog and runs his own technology and media consultancy.
Previous Article Hands On: Leica T
Next Article Hands on: Asus Fonepad 7
4 Comments
  • Jacob says:
    May 3, 2014 at 5:20 pm

    So what if there are more telcos? Like the petroleum companies, the prices are all fixed save for some confusing mix of discounts from this card, freebees from that card and what not. All in all a morass of plans cooked up with the blessings of PAP to confuse and take advantage of Singaporeans. Just look at the current bunch of telcos. All are working in cahoots and giving consumers practically no reason to choose one over the other. Now, if the PAP keep away from being involved in profiting from these companies, we may have some real competition yet.

    Reply
  • Jacob says:
    May 3, 2014 at 5:20 pm

    So what if there are more telcos? Like the petroleum companies, the prices are all fixed save for some confusing mix of discounts from this card, freebees from that card and what not. All in all a morass of plans cooked up with the blessings of PAP to confuse and take advantage of Singaporeans. Just look at the current bunch of telcos. All are working in cahoots and giving consumers practically no reason to choose one over the other. Now, if the PAP keep away from being involved in profiting from these companies, we may have some real competition yet.

    Reply
    • Lau says:
      January 1, 2015 at 1:56 am

      Your example of blaming the PAP responsible does not add any value to your argument and evaluation.

      Reply
      • Jacob says:
        January 2, 2015 at 4:07 pm

        Let me explain to you in simple words – the PAP government, through its investment vehicles, holds shares in commercial entities such as our telcos, petroleum companies, transport, etc. With such an arrangement, would PAP want to see its share value in these companies eroded through competition? Think, if you are able, and tell me why all of a sudden our telcos are now suddenly offering almost the same low mobile broadband quotas? Think, why all our high-profit making banks are now offering measly interest rates for deposits as well as charging many customers fees for putting their money with them? When the government has interests in a business, the people must lose. It is called conflicts of interests. The government is supposed to use taxpayers’ money to run the country to serve the taxpayers. Still want me to go on and educate you?

        Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow

Latest News

Beyond polls and editable messages, a few WhatsApp privacy, migration features we truly need
Internet Software June 7, 2023
Submarine cable landings to double in Singapore in ambitious blueprint to stay ahead digitally
Enterprise Internet Telecom June 6, 2023
Garmin Forerunner 965 review: Fully packed for serious fitness buffs
Mobile June 5, 2023
The best of Taiwanese innovation in cloud, AI, rollable screens and more at Asia Tech x Singapore
Audio-visual Enterprise Software June 5, 2023
//

Techgoondu.com is published by Goondu Media Pte Ltd, a company registered and based in Singapore.

.

Started in June 2008 by technology journalists and ex-journalists in Singapore who share a common love for all things geeky and digital, the site now includes segments on personal computing, enterprise IT and Internet culture.

banner banner
Everyday DIY
PC needs fixing? Get your hands on with the latest tech tips
READ ON
banner banner
Leaders Q&A
What tomorrow looks like to those at the leading edge today
FIND OUT
banner banner
Advertise with us
Discover unique access and impact with TG custom content
SHOW ME

 

 

POWERED BY READYSPACE
The Techgoondu website is powered by and managed by Readyspace Web Hosting.

TechgoonduTechgoondu
Follow US
© 2023 Goondu Media Pte Ltd. All Rights Reserved | Privacy | Terms of Use | Advertise | About Us | Contact
Join Us!

Never miss anything again. Get the latest news and analysis in your inbox.

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.
 

Loading Comments...
 

    Welcome Back!

    Sign in to your account

    Lost your password?