By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
TechgoonduTechgoondu
  • Audio-visual
  • Enterprise
    • Software
    • Cybersecurity
  • Gaming
  • Imaging
  • Internet
  • Media
  • Mobile
    • Cellphones
    • Tablets
  • PC
  • Telecom
Search
© 2023 Goondu Media Pte Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
Reading: TraceTogether debacle shows Singapore needs better data protection than a simple “trust us”
Share
Aa
TechgoonduTechgoondu
Aa
  • Audio-visual
  • Enterprise
  • Gaming
  • Imaging
  • Internet
  • Media
  • Mobile
  • PC
  • Telecom
Search
  • Audio-visual
  • Enterprise
    • Software
    • Cybersecurity
  • Gaming
  • Imaging
  • Internet
  • Media
  • Mobile
    • Cellphones
    • Tablets
  • PC
  • Telecom
Follow US
© 2023 Goondu Media Pte Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
Techgoondu > Blog > Internet > TraceTogether debacle shows Singapore needs better data protection than a simple “trust us”
Internet

TraceTogether debacle shows Singapore needs better data protection than a simple “trust us”

Alfred Siew
Last updated: January 6, 2021 at 12:44 AM
Alfred Siew Published January 5, 2021
5 Min Read
SHARE
SCREENSHOT: TraceTogether website

However you see it, the fact that TraceTogether can be used by the Singapore police to investigate so-called “serious” offences looks bad. This is not how you build trust.

To be sure, the revelation yesterday that the contact tracing data meant for fighting Covid-19 has been used in a murder investigation should be no surprise.

The Criminal Procedure Code, which grants the police broad powers to ask for “any document or other thing” for investigations, has been in place all this while.

That said, citizens had genuinely thought that TraceTogether was an exception. In a crisis, they wanted to trust the government in the fight against a deadly disease. They cooperated in good faith.

Minister-in-charge of the Smart Nation programme, Dr Vivian Balakrishnan, had given them an assurance last year.

He said the data collected was solely for contact tracing. He even went to lengths to explain that the TraceTogether token did not have GPS tracking or 4G connectivity so the data stayed in there.

Trust, after all, is built through concrete actions and here was a great attempt to do that. Independent experts were invited to tear down the token to verify what was inside.

Dr Balakrishnan now admits he had not thought of the wide-ranging powers that the police has in seizing data, including what’s on a TraceTogether token or app.

Trying to reassure citizens today, he explained that the data might be needed for serious crimes such as terrorism or murder.

Now, nobody will argue against the police having the right tools to combat these serious crimes, but what else might be considered serious crimes besides murder and terrorism?

Currently, the police have the authority to ask for data that is desirable or necessary for any investigation, inquiry, trial or other proceeding under the Criminal Procedure Code.

Dr Balakrishnan has said he is open to hearing suggestions to legislative changes. One way to fix this is to introduce amendments that require a stricter standard for the contact tracing data to be released for police investigations.

Already, the law spells out different types of data and who can ask for them. An officer with or above the rank of sergeant may ask for regular documents or data but an inspector or higher-ranking officer is needed to make a request for customer information from a financial institution.

So, clearly, some forms of data are considered more sensitive and important to citizens and thus require a higher bar for the police to access.

Can a similar provision be made for contact tracing data that citizens are providing for public health purposes? Perhaps a public prosecutor would be needed to make a case for access to that data.

The issue here goes beyond TraceTogether. Realistically speaking, the token or app holds limited data, compared to, say, your phone, which tracks your whereabouts and holds your private messages.

But what about other data that the government regularly collects from citizens? There surely have to be better safeguards than simply telling citizens to “trust us”.

With tighter legislation, you get more transparency, which helps build trust. Remember, without citizen buy-in, the fight against Covid-19 is going to be so much tougher. Privacy and trust are not mere conveniences here.

Another way to build trust is to set up an independent ombudsman’s office, of sorts, to look into data protection in the public sector.

It can represent citizens by recommending better practices and suggesting legislative amendments to better safeguard private data. Let’s be clear, citizens deserve better than this letdown.

Ironically, winning over citizens was exactly what the TraceTogether team had tried to do. What a pity. This episode is a reminder that trust is hard earned; sadly, it is also quickly lost.

You Might Also Like

Beyond polls and editable messages, a few WhatsApp privacy, migration features we truly need

Submarine cable landings to double in Singapore in ambitious blueprint to stay ahead digitally

Amid worries of scam calls, fake QR codes, companies aren’t helping with poor practices

Singapore WhatsApp users can now make payments straight from the app

Rising prices and low wages? Ask how platform companies have reshaped the economy

TAGGED: contact tracing, Covid-19, data protection, privacy, TraceTogether, Vivian Balakrishnan

Sign up for the TG newsletter

Never miss anything again. Get the latest news and analysis in your inbox.

By signing up, you agree to our Terms of Use and acknowledge the data practices in our Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Alfred Siew January 5, 2021
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Copy Link Print
Share
Avatar photo
By Alfred Siew
Follow:
Alfred is a writer, speaker and media instructor who has covered the telecom, media and technology scene for more than 20 years. Previously the technology correspondent for The Straits Times, he now edits the Techgoondu.com blog and runs his own technology and media consultancy.
Previous Article In 2021, will new technologies widen or close the digital divide?
Next Article StarHub to stream The Mandalorian and other shows after exclusive Disney+ deal
1 Comment
  • larry leong says:
    January 6, 2021 at 10:28 am

    There is “nothing much to worry”. Any users of Google & Apple devices already enable the authorities with the right correct level of ‘access & security clearance” to track any of the devices. Even without the TT App or Token, our devices are already emitting WIFI & BlueTooth beacons in our quest for “free wifi’ and bluetooth streaming of music.

    The TT token & TT App today, listen for all BlueTooth becons. Your device/App might record 100 BLE nearby, and maybe more than half will be untraceable directly as they might not be on the TT database. However, with proper clearance and supply chain mgt, they could trace to the first purhcaser/owner of the device, unless it was reported stolen.

    In the old computing days, we were given network cards (Especially Token Ring), where we need to change/clone the MAC address in order to access the SNA (nor SAN), network of the mainframes & AS/400…

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Stay Connected

Facebook Like
Twitter Follow

Latest News

Beyond polls and editable messages, a few WhatsApp privacy, migration features we truly need
Internet Software June 7, 2023
Submarine cable landings to double in Singapore in ambitious blueprint to stay ahead digitally
Enterprise Internet Telecom June 6, 2023
Garmin Forerunner 965 review: Fully packed for serious fitness buffs
Mobile June 5, 2023
The best of Taiwanese innovation in cloud, AI, rollable screens and more at Asia Tech x Singapore
Audio-visual Enterprise Software June 5, 2023
//

Techgoondu.com is published by Goondu Media Pte Ltd, a company registered and based in Singapore.

.

Started in June 2008 by technology journalists and ex-journalists in Singapore who share a common love for all things geeky and digital, the site now includes segments on personal computing, enterprise IT and Internet culture.

banner banner
Everyday DIY
PC needs fixing? Get your hands on with the latest tech tips
READ ON
banner banner
Leaders Q&A
What tomorrow looks like to those at the leading edge today
FIND OUT
banner banner
Advertise with us
Discover unique access and impact with TG custom content
SHOW ME

 

 

POWERED BY READYSPACE
The Techgoondu website is powered by and managed by Readyspace Web Hosting.

TechgoonduTechgoondu
Follow US
© 2023 Goondu Media Pte Ltd. All Rights Reserved | Privacy | Terms of Use | Advertise | About Us | Contact
Join Us!

Never miss anything again. Get the latest news and analysis in your inbox.

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.
 

Loading Comments...
 

    Welcome Back!

    Sign in to your account

    Lost your password?