Goondu review: Huawei P20 Pro moves mobile photography up a notch

April 7th, 2018 | by Wilson Wong
Goondu review: Huawei P20 Pro moves mobile photography up a notch
Cellphones
6

PHOTO: Handout

By now, you may have heard how well Huawei’s new flagship, the P20 Pro, performs in terms of its camera.

I’m here to say you read right – the phone revealed just last week moves mobile photography forwards in a giant leap.

Let’s start with the much-talked-about rear camera that sports no fewer than three sensors – one for colour, one for monochrome and one for zoom.

This is unlike other multiple-camera setups today, say, with Samsung, LG or Apple. On LG’s V30+, for example, the two lenses work independently, one for wide-angle shots and one for more regular pictures, like your portrait or food images.

What Huawei does with the P20 Pro, as it has done before, is to take the images from all its sensors and put together a single image. This, as I found, is better than what many a single lens can usually do.

The P20 Pro now comes with a three-sensor camera system that works together to create impressive image quality. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

The P20 Pro’s three sensors in the rear camera include a 40-megapixel colour sensor (with f1.8 aperture lens), a 20-megapixel black-and-white sensor (with f1.6 aperture lens) and a 8-megapixel colour sensor with 3x zoom (with f2.4 aperture lens). All three go to work when you fire away.

It helps too that the colour sensor is 1/1.7-inch in size, which is the largest currently for a smartphone. Samsung’s Galaxy S9+, in comparison, comes with a 1/2.55-incher.

Using a bigger sensor with more megapixels has its advantages. On top of having a larger file to use for post-editing by the camera, it also allows smoother colour graduation from bright to dark areas for much better colour reproduction.

The hardware is one thing. By combining the information gathered from the sensors with artificial intelligence-enabled image stabilisation, Huawei’s P20 Pro has more headroom to correct camera shakes.

That’s not all. To increase the sensitivity of the sensor, the engineers at Leica decided to use a method called light fusion which is similar to pixel binning.

The camera system uses four pixels on the sensor to create one single pixel in the recorded image. This reduces the chance of having unwanted pixel noise or ISO noise while enabling a much higher ISO setting of 102400, which is unheard of on a smartphone.

I put the phone on the floor, inside the puddle of water thanks to the water resistance of the P20 Pro, which has an IP67 rating. I fired up the Night Mode and, in 4 seconds, this shot was taken. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

Leica has also introduced an in-camera post-editing algorithm that mimics how professional photographers edit their photos in Lightroom and Photoshop called Image Blending to create High Dynamic Range (HDR) images.

This useful for capturing difficult lighting situations such as sunsets or sunrises and low-light conditions, while minimising ISO noise.

When putting all these improvements together, the P20 Pro can now capture a night scene in HDR using a four-second long exposure without the need of a tripod. In photography terms, you can say that’s a miracle.

Handheld shot of the streets of Paris with a four-second long exposure. The details are eye-poppingly sharp, without the use of a tripod. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

The result is simply breathtaking and the experience of using the phone to shoot night scenes is liberating. I am now more mobile without dragging the tripod with me.

The images that came out of the camera are close to what I would create with Photoshop and Lightroom too and that saves a lot of time in front of the PC.

The P20 Pro’s night mode with a 4-second exposure. Handheld. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

The P20 Pro’s night mode at f1.8, 12.6 seconds at ISO 100 on tripod. If I have the time to work on the shot, I’d prefer the much longer exposure. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

Shot with the Canon 200D with its 18-55 kit lens. I took five shots of various exposures from 20 seconds to 1 second on a tripod and combined them in Photoshop. I did some colour correction as well to match up closely to the P20 Pro image as much as possible. I could still do dodging and burning to match the brightness but the total time used for this shot is now much more than the time used by the smartphone. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

I would have thought that having such a great night shooting experience is enough to sell the P20 Pro but Huawei has another trick up its sleeves.

One of the weaknesses of a smartphone camera is the lackluster zoom capabilities. Over the years, I have seen different ways to incorporate an optical zoom system into the phone, from Samsung’s Galaxy K Zoom to the more recent Lenovo Moto Z Hasselblad Camera Module.

With these past efforts, the zoom’s reach could be pretty decent, but the image quality typically wasn’t that great.

Leica’s solution for the P20 Pro involves the use of the 8-megapixel sensor with a 3x zoom. Together with the other two sensors, it is able to produce a 5x “hybrid zoom” image.

I have been quite impressed by the quality from these composite images. No, actually, they are stunning in showing sharp details and without any loss of contrast or colour.

Using the main sensor, this is the wide-angle lens at 27mm equivalent. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

To get to 3x zoom, the camera switches to the zoom sensor, giving it an 80mm equivalent shot.

The P20 Pro combines the data from its three sensors to derive a 5x hybrid zoom image. In good light, the image quality is superb. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

Like the Mate 10 Pro previously, Huawei continues to make use of its own Kirin 970 processor’s AI features in the P20 and P20 Pro.

The camera not only recognises the subject – it can apply 19 different combinations of the shutter, white balance (colour) and bokeh settings to fit the subject matter.

It can also suggests ways for you to take a photo, like providing a guide box on the screen to get everyone in a group shot. It even automatically zooms into the subject for a close-up shot if you are taking a macro shot of a toy or flower, which is very impressive.

The Close Up mode is certainly impressive. However, this mode works best when activated by the camera’s AI. I can activate it manually by lowering my image quality to 10 megapixels in the settings first before activating the 3x or 5x zooms to get a closer macro shot. I wish there’s a way for me to choose the mode manually. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

The P20 Pro’s food shot mode tends to be a bit more saturated than necessary. I will usually use the normal Photo mode to shoot. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

Nothing’s perfect, of course. There were times the AI didn’t kick in and I had to manually engage the zoom by switching my image quality settings from 40 megapixels to 10 megapixels first before triggering the zoom button.

I wish that whenever I zoomed in, the phone would switch the image quality to 10 megapixels automatically and back when I am done.

The P20 Pro is certainly an imaging powerhouse among competing smartphones now. It clocks a high score of 109 on the well-followed DXOMark test, though it still has some areas to improve on.

For example, by using Pixel Binning, all the images captured by the phone have only 10 megapixels in all but the Pro (manual) Mode.

Ten-megapixel image files may seem small at first but they are definitely more than enough to be used for printing of A4- or Super 8R-sized photos and online photo sharing.

Like the Mate 10 Pro, you get just one USB-C port at the bottom and no headphone jack. There’s no microSD card slot either. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

What I do feel is grossly inadequate is the storage capacity, a “happy” problem brought about by the 40-megapixel sensor.

Huawei could argue that the 128GB internal storage is enough for most users but having a microSD card slot is certainly essential to serious photography enthusiasts.

You do want more storage to save the huge 79MB RAW image files from the 40-megapixel sensor, especially if you want them for post-processing later on a computer.

My shot of Laura, our tour guide during the launch of the Huawei phone in Europe. The portrait mode with nice bokeh in the background is pretty good. The subject extraction has improved overall but still, the algorithm may have trouble when the objects in the foreground and the background are of similar colour, like the white charging wire coming out of the power bank. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

If you are fond of taking portraits, the P20 Pro is a great tool to do that. The bokeh effect is now rendered very nicely and the subject is extracted more accurately. The P20 Pro has certainly improved upon the Mate 10 Pro.

This was shot in Photo (automatic) mode and the portrait mode was activated on the fly. When everything works, the image is outstanding. PHOTO: Wilson Wong.

The selfie camera’s 24 megapixels are good too. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

Among the imaging enhancements, one thing I am not crazy about is the slow-mo video capture. It’s another me-too feature after Sony and Samsung both introduced it earlier.

Like Samsung, Huawei only offers this at 720p resolution. Surprisingly, in sufficient light, it is pretty good. Great for sharing on social media, where resolution may not be an issue.

Then again, capturing a good slow-mo video can be a hair pulling experience. To capture successful footage, I must time my shutter accurately to the start of the action sequence and the camera’s user interface is not helpful at all.

My experience with Sony’s Xperia XZ Premium is definitely better in this regard. If you are into slow motion video, this is something you need to try and decide for yourself.

Inevitably, a review of the P20 Pro will involve its imaging functions, since they are the breakthrough features and main selling point.

Fortunately, the rest of the hardware isn’t shabby, either. The Huawei Kirin chip, which powers the AI in the phone is no slouch. And with 6GB of RAM and a 6.1-inch OLED screen, it brings what you expect of flagship phones today.

The 4,000mAh battery works well, despite my heavy usage during the trial period. Even after 20 minutes of shooting a time-lapse footage, it took up only 5 per cent of battery power. The power pack can last a whole day of usage pretty comfortably.

What are the potential deal breakers on the P20 Pro, despite its obvious appeal? One is the lack of a microSD card slot, something that many Android users are so used to.

For music lovers, the lack of the 3.5mm headphone jack on the P20/P20 Pro will be painful as well. Huawei has responded by providing Bluetooth audio connection via aptX. Is that a good compromise?

Not when you still have expensive wired headsets lying around. Yes, you can use an adapter to plug into the USB-C port but that would mean you can’t charge the phone while listening to your favourite tunes.

Another potential deal breaker for the P20 Pro has to be the controversial notch.

Sure, you can push the notifications to the corners of the phone and squeeze the speaker and front-facing camera into the empty space between the on-screen notifications.

You can also argue that it actually helps to increase the usable screen estate on the phone while keeping the phone sleek.

Unfortunately, the notch is now synonymous with the iPhone X which has polarised both users of Apple and Android phones alike.

The notch helps to maintain the sleekness of the phone and yet maximise the usable screen estate. It can be distracting at times though the black bar afforded by the OLED screen hides it well. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

Thankfully, Huawei allows users to “switch off” the notch by introducing a black bar across the top end of the screen. Even if you do keep the notch, it will still not obscure your viewing pleasure when you stream your favourite YouTube or Netflix videos.

The notch does block the top of my Instagram app though, so certain apps have to be updated to avoid the notch altogether. There’s no telling if and when developers would do so.

Unfortunately, going with the notch really brings unnecessary attention to a phone that is excellent in the one thing that will attract buyers – its camera.

The image quality on the P20 Pro has certainly performed beyond my expectations. To be sure, it still won’t trump good images from mirrorless and DSLR cameras, at least not in the near term.

And despite advances, AI can’t solve all problems. You still need the skills, knowledge and experience to get a good image at times.

All the same, the P20 Pro has moved mobile photography up a notch. It should be high on your list if your smartphone images mean anything to you.

Costing S$1,148 in Singapore, the P20 Pro is also competitively priced against Samsung’s Galaxy S9 and S9+ (S$1,198 and S$1,348).

You get black and midnight blue now for colours, and if you wait until next month, the eye-catching Twilight option will be out. That’s the colour I’d get for a phone that is already highly impressive.

PHOTO
GALLERY

6 Comments

  1. Simon Gray. says:

    Great review Wilson, my dilemma is do I want a camera based phone or an Internet device sans Galaxy Note 9. Your pictures have sold me on the P20 Pro and after 2yrs with Hauwai I am comfortable with there AI. When it is time to change I will have a difficult choice

    • Wilson Wong says:

      I can safely say any phone you get will be internet ready. As a camera, the image quality is subjective but the main thing that p20 did well is how it captures images. Good look in choosing phones when the time comes.

  2. Sufian Ramli says:

    Honestly it does not beat the S9+ outright though

    • Wilson Wong says:

      Perhaps my photography skills didn’t do justice to the phone but as far as I am concerned, definitely subjective of course, is not about just the image quality but how the image was captured easily by the user.

      I do prefer the more natural color representation afforded by the P20 Pro over the Samsung’s more saturated version because that have me a bit more leeway to edit should I need to.

      In the end we do have options to buy other phones because ultimately, our tastes are subjective.

      Thanks for your comments.

  3. Filip says:

    Thank you for great review. Night shots you took looks amazing. I am getting mine P20 Pro next week or so. Now I am little a bit confused about colors available. Are you talking about your market or generaly? I would like to get Twilight one, but don’t want to wait one more month. I am from Europe.

    • Alfred Siew says:

      Hi Filip,

      Yes, this is for Singapore. Sorry for the confusion. We have updated the story to reflect this better.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.