breaking news

Goondu review: Huawei Mate 10 Pro

October 24th, 2017 | by Wilson Wong
Goondu review: Huawei Mate 10 Pro
Cellphones
8

Huawei’s Mate 10 Pro is the company’s most ambitious attempt yet to cement its new Number Two market position. PHOTO: Handout

Huawei’s Mate 10 series, launched just last week, is the Chinese phone maker’s most ambitious phone so far. 

Having used the Mate 10 Pro for the past few days, I have to say it is also the most innovative yet, with the new Kirin 970 chip powering its headline artificial intelligence (AI) features.

What you get on the phone goes beyond the gimmicky. There are functional and feature-led improvements that bring real performance and efficiency to everyday tasks, such as photography.

AI is not new but one grouse has been the need to connect to the cloud to get the relevant information. With the Kirin 970 chip, the Mate 10 Pro processes the data on the phone to respond faster in some instances.

This is shown in the phone’s camera system. When I shoot a portrait, I would expect a much more natural skin tone colour. Meanwhile, a sunset should look great with greater saturation of the warmer colours.

The Mate 10 Pro’s camera has also done a great job with ISO noise reduction for night shots. At the same time, more details pop out too. Bottomline: Another impressive camera from Huawei.

The Asian skin tone is always a handful for cameras to recreate but the Mate 10 Pro did well here. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

The phone’s wide aperture effect has also improved from previous Huawei phones, though it still is a handful if the background is too complex. All the same, the Mate 10 Pro’s camera is a joy to use. With any quick point-and-shoot, I am confident of a very decent image.

For sure, Huawei’s partnership with Leica in recent years has helped here. Now in its second iteration, the camera in the Mate 10 Pro enjoys a huge physical improvement as well. It now sports a large-aperture f1.6 Summilux-H lens that provides a 27mm focal length equivalent to what you get on a DSLR camera.

Even though the Mate 10 Pro still has the same 20-megapixel black-and-white sensor and 12-megapixel colour sensor in its dual-lens setup, the new smartphone is now able to recognise 13 different scenes and process the images accordingly.

Once you have a focus lock, you don’t have to lift the finger to drag the brightness cursor out of the lock. You can get the camera to expose the part of the frame where the brightness cursor rests. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

For avid photographers, there are still manual controls for more precise settings. RAW images in the open DNG file format can be saved in manual mode for post-editing later with your favourite image editor.

Having said that, the camera is still not totally foolproof and I prefer to exercise discretion when it comes to exposure. The phone’s light meter, like all other cameras, can be tricked.

Good news is, the controls are handy. I just poke at the location I want to focus, then hold the button and drag it to a place in the frame where I want the camera to expose. I can also do the same by dragging the brightness level on the right of the focus point.

Monochrome dynamic range test. There are still details in the sky and shadows here. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

Even a back-lit window shot such as this is handled expertly. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

Macro shot of flower with the natural bokeh thanks to the new f1.6 Summilux-H lens. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

Macro shot of toy figurine with the natural bokeh thanks to the new f1.6 Summilux-H lens. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

The phone’s wide aperture effect creates very interesting shots. However, the subject extraction hits a snag when the background is more complex. The area around the right forearm does not ‘bokeh’ out. PHOTO: Wilson Wong.

There is also a new 3D Panorama shooting mode that creates a 3D image from a set of images as you shoot around a subject matter. The only bummer is that you have to share the photo via the proprietary Fyuse viewer, the creator of 3D Panorama.

With so many pictures to shoot, it’s a good thing the Mate 10 Pro has ample power to last a day or more. The phone itself is frugal when it comes to battery usage, so the large 4,000mAh power pack is more than sufficient go get through a day.

It survived a 24-hour stint during my flight back to Singapore from Munich, Germany via Frankfurt. I was posting on social media whenever had Internet access and I watched four episodes of downloaded Netflix shows while in the air.

When I reached home, I spent another three hours playing mobile games, and the phone stared at me with 10 per cent of juice left. Impressive, indeed.

Much of this is down to the power-efficient Kirin 970 chip, which has improved on many areas in the phone.

Google Maps seems snappier, say, when you come out from the KPE or CTE underground tunnels. Google Assistant is also more responsive and can pick up my voice quickly thanks to improved voice recognition.

The infrared transmitter onboard allows the phone to be used as a controller. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

For all the improvements, it has to be noted that the Mate 10 Pro lacks two things many Android users want – a 3.5mm headphone jack and a microSD card sl0t.

I know the rationale – Bluetooth earphones are starting to be affordable with good audio performance and microSD cards, especially slow ones, will make the phone feel sluggish as it retrieves information.

There isn’t a 3.5mm headphone jack so you have to sacrifice the USB Type-C port to be used as a headphone port with the included adapter. Otherwise, Bluetooth headphones are what you need. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

However, the good old headphone jack is still very practical – for one, wired headphones don’t require any batteries to operate. A fast microSD card now can be had on the cheap too and your data can be transferred quickly too when you upgrade to a new phone.

These could be deal breakers for some potential buyers. They might actually go for the cheaper Mate 10, which is supposed to be lower-end but has some features missing in its Pro brethren.

The Mate 10 actually sports a microSD card slot and headphone jack. It has a slightly smaller 5.9-inch LCD screen but it is sharper at 2,560 x 1,440 resolution. Okay, the Mate 10 has only 4GB memory and 64GB storage, but it is not poorer in all aspects.

This can be a bit confusing for consumers, who might assume the Pro version should have more features. Okay, it does have 6GB of memory and 128GB pf internal storage, but its screen is less sharp than the plain vanilla Mate 10.

The Pro version has a 6-inch OLED screen but this comes only in 2,160 x 1080 (FHD+), so you could say it doesn’t have the clearly superior hardware. This is an area Huawei should address in future.

The Mate 10, with its higher-resolution IPS LCD screen, may be seen as a better deal than the Mate 10 Pro. PHOTO: Handout.

To be fair, I am very comfortable using the Mate 10 Pro’s elongated screen. With a wide colour gamut being represented, it should be the phone that avid photographers would go for in terms of colour accuracy.

It also forgoes the curved screen like on the Mate 9 Pro and Samsung Galaxy S8+, which is a good thing. There’s no unnecessary light reflection when I watch my favourite movie.

Finally, in terms of looks, the Mate 10 Pro is attractive. It’s sleek yet comfortable enough to hold securely, though you have to wipe off all the oily fingerprints at the end of the day. Thank goodness there’s a plastic phone casing that comes with the phone. Bad new is, you don’t get to enjoy the pretty design with it on.

The look of the Mate 10 and Mate 10 Pro is a departure from the metal uni-block look of the Mate 8 and Mate 9. For those who like what other phone makers have come up with of late, this glass and shiny finish is good news.

I still think Huawei should spend more effort to differentiate itself from the competition. A carbon fibre or ceramic phone next perhaps? What about other form factors?

I am definitely not a fan of glass-backed devices. Yes, it looks luxurious but the beautiful surface will have to be covered by a case or you’ll have to be careful not to drop it. PHOTO: Wilson Wong

If you are interested in the Mate 10 Pro, only Black and Mocha Brown will be available in Singapore next month. Unfortunately, the other two colours, Titanium Grey and Midnight Blue, won’t be out here.

What surprises me more is the starting price of the Mate 10 series. The basic Mate 10 costs “only” S$888 when it is launched later this month but there is no word on the Mate 10 Pro’s local retail price.

Judging from the feature set, the Mate 10’s price at launch is attractive. This is when compared to other flagships, such as the Samsung Galaxy Note 8 (S$1398), Google Pixel 2 XL ($1,159) and HTC U11 (S$998).

I expect the Mate 10 Pro’s price won’t be too far off, given the European price difference of €100. We will only know when the phone is launched in Singapore at the end of this month, but if it follows the price elsewhere, it should be competitively priced as well.

PHOTO
GALLERY

8 Comments

  1. amazingwalks says:

    Dear Wilson, I have read 2 reviews that mention that Mate 10/10 Pro have network/signal issues. What is your take on this?

    • Wilson Wong says:

      Hello!

      Right now I am replying this in the middle of suburban Japan using Docomo. And have tested with German using UK’s EE and Singapore networks with SingTel. It works wirelessly with my drone via WiFi and I could send files effortlessly never mind getting on Facebook and instagram.

      I suspect has to do with the actual network setup by the provider.

  2. Noel says:

    Hi Wilson, with the LG POLED debacle on both the v30 and pixel 2 XL, how’s the oled on the Mate 10.

    Also would you say that it’s worth upgrading to from a Mate 9?

    • Hi Noel, I didn’t see any discernible issues with the screen after 1 week of use.

      As for upgrading from Mate 9 I feel the older model is still going strong thanks to the self-learning feature that actively keep track of your usage pattern and manage the phone’s resources accordingly. I know that because mine is still going strong and there is not much difference in speed.

      If the Mate 9 can last you the whole day, I think you can keep it. However if you are like me that do photography, photo editing, video, video editing and drone flying, then having a more efficient processor like the Kirin 970 will help as it will help maintain battery power throughout the day.

      For those who have P9 or would like a camera -centric phone, then the Mate 10 does deliver. If compared to Mate 9, there are differences but if you can’t see it, then best to keep using the Mate 9. For me, the lens itself and the camera image processor has done a good job with low light photography (you can see some of the photos being uploaded in the image gallery).

      Judging by the way Huawei has improved over the years, who knows P11 will be another giant leap.

      Thanks for following Techgoondu.

      • Noel says:

        Therein lies my issue

        The 960 was so fast for its time that it’s still up there with all the other flagships. The only two real advantages are for the AI chip and larger aperture. Looks like I’ll have to think about if it’s worth the extra cash as spent as my 9 is still really quick.

        • Wilson Wong says:

          I agree the Kirin 960 is fast enough and the AI chip is at its birth stages. When more apps make full use of the processing power, the buy case will be stronger. For now the camera has improved lots and if one is not an avid photographer perhaps the decision process is tougher

  3. Huawei MATE 8,bought a year ago,GAVE ME A LOT OF PROBLEMS,after each UI update from Huawei.

    Won’t touch anymore OF Huawei’s phones,BUT,am planning to buy the Xiaomi MI MAX 3,which is the BEST VALUE SMARTPHONE OF THEM ALL !!!

Leave a Reply

UA-8246182-4